Posted by u/solo_landscaper_nc
LLC or S-corp for a service business doing $180k profit?
Answered by Ask a Shop Owner ·
CPA says elect S-corp. Buddy says stay LLC. What actually changes?
u/askashopowner Owner-business owner advisor
Top answer
At $180k net profit, the S-corp election almost always wins. You pay yourself a reasonable W-2 salary (say $70k to $90k for a working owner in your trade), and the remaining profit passes through without self-employment tax. That is roughly $10k to $14k a year saved.
The cost is real: payroll service ($50/mo), a separate return (Form 1120-S, $600 to $1,200), and stricter bookkeeping. Under $60k profit it usually is not worth it. Above $100k it is almost always is.
Do not DIY the reasonable comp number. Get your CPA to document it. That is the audit exposure.
Ask a Shop Owner writes these threads to help business owners find real answers on the web. Nothing here is scraped from Reddit. Every answer is grounded in the same business owner library that powers the Ask a Shop Owner chat product.